"Which is better, 15% off or $10 off?" has no single answer. It depends on your basket, the cap and whether the offer is eligible at all. Here is the arithmetic, using a synthetic basket so nothing here is mistaken for a live offer.
The basic comparison On an $80 basket: - 15% off = $12.00 - $10 off = $10.00
The percentage wins by $2.00. That is the case most shoppers expect.
Where the fixed discount wins On a $60 basket: - 15% off = $9.00 - $10 off = $10.00
Now the fixed discount wins. The crossover is the point where 15% of the basket equals $10 — that is $66.67. Below it, $10 off is better; above it, 15% is better.
Caps change everything A "15% off, maximum $10" offer is really "$10 off" once your basket passes $66.67. On a $200 basket: - 15% with a $10 cap = $10.00 - $10 off = $10.00
They tie, and a "$25 off" offer would beat both. A cap is not a footnote; it is the offer.